Strategies For Dealing With Insurance Companies Post-Accident

Dealing with insurance companies can be challenging and frustrating, especially when you don't know the procedure.
Clayton T. Hasbrook

Written by Clayton T. Hasbrook. Last modified on February 20, 2024

Office Information
Hasbrook & Hasbrook
400 N Walker Ave #130, Oklahoma City, OK

Dealing with insurance companies after an accident, whether it involves medical bills, car repairs, or home damage, can overwhelm even the most informed customers. However, with the right approach, you can turn insurance frustrations into rewarding outcomes – ensuring you receive what the insurance company rightfully owes you.

Free Consult With an Experienced Attorney

While you might handle straightforward claims on your own, certain complex situations necessitate legal advice. Serious injuries that require ongoing treatment and have long-term effects, for example, warrant the involvement of a skilled personal injury lawyer to secure comprehensive compensation, including for future costs.

Similarly, claims involving disputed fault or multiple parties benefit from an attorney’s ability to resolve such complexities. If the insurance offer seems insufficient for the losses incurred, a lawyer might negotiate more aggressively or take legal action if necessary to achieve fair compensation.

While simple claims might be navigated without legal help, the involvement of legal counsel provides significant benefits in more complicated scenarios. Lawyers are adept at estimating future costs, establishing liability, and determining appropriate compensation. They often secure more favorable settlements than individuals might on their own. Thus, involving a qualified lawyer is advisable when facing resistance from insurers or legal uncertainties.

Understand Your Policy

Before initiating an insurance claim, reviewing your policy documents to understand your coverage is important. Pay close attention to coverage limits, deductibles, exclusions, and other critical policy details.

A deep understanding of your insurance coverage will help you make informed decisions and avoid disputes when filing a claim. For example, your auto policy might cover collision damage but not normal wear and tear. Recognizing this distinction can prevent unnecessary conflicts. You wouldn’t file a claim for a worn-out transmission, which is typically excluded under wear-and-tear provisions.

Document Everything

take photos at the accident scene
Document and photograph everything at the accident scene.

Document and photograph everything at the accident scene.

Comprehensive documentation is your best ally when dealing with insurance companies. Document all interactions with the insurer through phone calls, emails, or letters. Note the date, time, representative’s name, and conversation summary.

For instance, if you inquire about coverage for a specific procedure, document the call’s details, including the representative’s name, the information provided, and any reference numbers.

Additionally, secure the police report, which offers an objective account of the incident. Exchange contact information with all involved parties, including witnesses. Take photographs of all vehicle damage, the scene, and any injuries. Keep medical records, from initial treatment to ongoing care, and note any missed workdays or lost income due to the accident.

While documenting everything requires effort, it provides protection and evidence if disputes arise later. Start gathering evidence immediately after an accident to prevent future headaches.

Follow The Insurance Company’s Procedures

property adjuster inspecting car damage

Each insurance company has specific protocols for submitting claims. To avoid complications, follow all outlined steps and requirements. Ignoring these procedures could delay or jeopardize your claim.

For example, contact your homeowners’ insurer immediately after storm damage to start the claims process. You might need to fill out claim forms, obtain repair estimates, and allow the adjuster to inspect the damage. Adhering to these guidelines and timelines shows your commitment to the process.

For car accident claims, you typically need to submit a crash report, repair invoices, and medical expense documentation. Organized records submitted according to the insurer’s guidelines can expedite claim approval.

Prepared To File The Claim

When you’re ready to file your claim, ensure all relevant documentation and details are compiled and organized. For a car accident claim, provide clear evidence like the police report, photos of damages, and witness statements. Comprehensive supporting documents strengthen your case and promote efficient processing.

Also, include all medical bills, records of lost income, and repair estimates. Itemized, organized records support your compensation request. However, refrain from overwhelming your insurer with unnecessary documents. Aim for conciseness yet thoroughness.

For home insurance claims resulting from theft or disaster, provide annotated lists of damaged items, receipts, or other proof of value. Photos or videos of the damage further substantiate your claim.

Communicate Clearly And Concisely

When communicating with your insurance company, aim for clarity and conciseness. Use straightforward language to convey the necessary information without digressing.

For instance, when filing a claim, detail essential information like the date, surgeon, hospital, and total cost of the procedure. Avoid rambling or allowing emotions to obscure the facts. Focus on relevant details without unnecessary elaboration.

While being thorough is important, steer clear of repetitive or irrelevant information that could undermine your explanation. Be strategic and direct, providing the insurer with exactly what they need in a succinct manner.

Don’t Accept The First Offer

Insurance companies often start negotiations with a settlement offer, especially for accident or property damage claims. However, it’s advisable not to accept the first offer without careful consideration.

For example, if your car is significantly damaged in a crash, the initial settlement might not fully cover the repairs or account for the vehicle’s diminished value. In such cases, negotiate firmly but politely for fair compensation.

Remember, insurers aim to minimize costs with initial low offers, but you have influence in the claims process. Stand firm and present your case assertively and professionally, highlighting evidence if the offer seems to undervalue your losses.

Be Patient And Persistent

The insurance claims process requires patience; compensation can take weeks or months to finalize. However, persistence is just as important when dealing with insurers.

For example, if your homeowner’s claim remains unanswered after submission, follow up persistently within a reasonable timeframe. Consistent yet patient communication keeps your claim on the insurer’s radar, preventing it from being overlooked.

While expecting delays, don’t allow excessive waiting without updates. Inquire at appropriate intervals to show active interest in resolving the claim. If the process extends beyond reasonable timeframes, escalate your inquiries to hasten the process. Balancing patience with persistence can help achieve timely resolution.

Final Recommendations

When in doubt, consult a lawyer. Personal injury attorneys often offer free consultations, providing an opportunity to ensure nothing is overlooked in your claim. Dealing with insurance claims can be challenging, but you can navigate the process by understanding your policy, meticulously documenting interactions, and adhering to procedures. Professional assistance is available if you encounter obstacles.

By following these steps, you can manage your insurance claims efficiently and secure the maximum compensation. Don’t let the process intimidate you. You can achieve a favorable outcome with proper preparation, documentation, and persistence.

Car Accident FAQs

What should I do immediately after an accident?

Immediately after an accident, ensure everyone’s safety and call emergency services. You should exchange contact and insurance information with the other parties involved. Document the scene with photos and notes, and report the accident to your insurance company.

How do I know if I need a lawyer for my insurance claim?

Consider hiring a lawyer if your claim involves significant injuries, disputed fault, or complex legal issues. A lawyer can provide valuable guidance, negotiate with insurance companies on your behalf, and represent you in court if necessary. At the very least, meet with a lawyer to ensure you are not missing anything on your claim.

Can I negotiate my insurance settlement?

Yes, you can negotiate your insurance settlement. If the initial offer from the insurance company seems low, present evidence such as repair estimates, medical bills, and documentation of lost wages to support your case for a higher settlement. If the insurance company continues to be unreasonable, hire a lawyer.

What if my insurance claim is denied?

If your insurance claim is denied, review the insurer’s reasons for denial and check your policy to understand the coverage. You can appeal the decision by providing additional documentation or evidence. Consulting a lawyer can also help you navigate the appeal process and if the insurance company handles your claim in bad faith.

How long does the insurance claim process take?

The duration of the insurance claim process varies depending on the complexity of the claim, the amount of documentation required, and the efficiency of the insurance company. It can range from a few weeks to several months. Maintaining open communication with your insurer and providing requested documentation promptly can help expedite the process.

What is the best way to document my insurance claim?

The best way to document your insurance claim is to keep a detailed record of all communications with the insurance company, including dates, names, and summaries of conversations. Collect and organize all relevant documents, such as police reports, medical records, repair estimates, and photographs of the damage.

How can I ensure my insurance claim is processed smoothly?

To ensure your insurance claim is processed smoothly, thoroughly understand your policy coverage, follow the insurance company’s procedures for filing a claim, and provide comprehensive documentation. Communicate clearly and persistently follow up on the status of your claim.

What are common mistakes to avoid when filing an insurance claim?

Common mistakes to avoid when filing an insurance claim include failing to understand your policy coverage, not documenting the claim adequately, missing deadlines for filing claims or submitting documentation, and accepting the first settlement offer without negotiation.

How do I handle disputes with my insurance company?

Handle disputes with your insurance company by reviewing your policy to ensure you understand your coverage, presenting clear evidence to support your claim, and communicating your concerns effectively. Consider mediation or legal action if disputes persist, and consult a lawyer for guidance.

Can I file an insurance claim without a police report?

While it’s possible to file an insurance claim without a police report, having one can strengthen your claim by providing an official account of the incident. Some insurance policies may require a police report for certain types of claims, so checking your policy requirements is important.


This page has been written, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. This page was approved by Founding Partner, Clayton T. Hasbrook who has years of legal experience as a personal injury lawyer. Our last modified date shows when this page was last reviewed.