IME – The (not so) Independent Medical Exam

There is no “i” in team, and there shouldn’t be one in “IME,” either, because there is nothing “independent” about an IME in a personal injury lawsuit. In fact, plaintiffs' personal injury attorneys are more properly referring to these exams as DMEs, or “Defendant Medical Exams,” or “Insurance Medical Exams.” For purposes of this article, I will use the term “IME” only because it is the term used by the insurance companies and their lawyers, but make no mistake about it: IMEs are in no way impartial, independent, or any other “i” word implying lack of bias.
Office Information
Hasbrook & Hasbrook
400 N Walker Ave #130, Oklahoma City, OK
Phone: (405) 605-2426

What is an Insurance Medical Exam?

So, what is an IME? In a personal injury lawsuit, an IME is a medical exam that the plaintiff must undergo at the defendant’s request, using the defendant’s choice of doctor, pursuant to discovery rules. While plaintiffs’ attorneys can have their clients undergo an IME using a doctor of their own choice, plaintiffs only need to be wary of the IMEs ordered by the defense (and these are the types of IMEs that I refer to throughout this article). Why? Because the purpose of the IME is to prepare the defendant’s expert witness — the IME doctor — to testify that you are not hurt, or that you are not hurt as badly as you say you are, or if you were hurt, you have fully recovered well before your treatment was over. Sometimes, it is used to prematurely place you at MMI to cut off your future medical care. The IME doctor knows who hired him or her and for what purpose, and if he or she ever wants to be hired by another defense attorney again (this is a lucrative repeat-business prospect), the doctor will slant their opinions to be as unfavorable to your case as possible. Knowing this, how can you minimize the damage caused by an IME?

How to Handle the Exam Itself

You will receive plenty of advance notice from your attorney when the defendant has scheduled you for an IME. You will know the name of the doctor conducting the exam and his or her specialty (orthopedic, neurologist, chiropractor — depending on the nature of your injury). Your attorney may know this doctor and what to expect from him or her, as many are repeat players that your attorney has encountered before in other lawsuits. Listen carefully to any advice your lawyer gives, as he or she will know any tricks this doctor has employed in the past. Your attorney will also let you know if someone from his or her office will attend the IME (such as your lawyer, a paralegal, or a videographer). Rules for attendance by your side vary among jurisdictions, and lawyers have different approaches. First, you must realize that you may be watched from the moment you arrive at the doctor’s office. Some IME doctors are zealous enough to watch the plaintiff enter the parking lot and, as they leave, see if the plaintiff lifts anything or walks differently when he or she doesn’t think the “patient” is being watched. Be cognizant of your behavior in the waiting room. If you claim trouble sitting for an extended period, be sure you don’t sit still in the waiting room should the doctor decide to make you wait for an hour.

Take note of when your exam with the doctor starts and ends.

It will be surprisingly short in most cases (maybe even 10 minutes). Write it down. Your attorney can later use this to cross-examine the IME doctor. Expect that the doctor will have you fill out a questionnaire regarding your medical history and current condition. If you need to bring some notes to remember some of these things, do so. Describe your medical problems consistently with how you have described them to your treating doctors. If you told your treating doctor your pain is a “6 on a 10 scale,” don’t suddenly up it to a “10” at your IME (unless you can explain what worsened your pain). Despite the fact that you filled out this questionnaire, the doctor will probably ask you many of the same questions during your physical exam. Feel free to refer the doctor to the questionnaire if you’ve already answered the question there. Asking you the same question twice is just a way to try to catch you in an inconsistency. Also, beware of the doctor trying to conduct his deposition of you during the exam. If he or she is asking you questions about how the accident happened that do not affect your injuries (like whether the light was green or red), let the doctor know that you don’t feel comfortable answering that question before speaking with your lawyer. Then, call your lawyer and see if he or she wants you to answer the doctor’s question. Usually, if a doctor tries to pull these kinds of shenanigans, calling your lawyer will end it. Odds are, if your deposition has already been taken in this lawsuit, the doctor has received and read it before your exam, so there’s no reason for the IME doctor to need to ask those questions.

Do Not Exaggerate

Despite the fact that the IME doctor is trying to hurt your case, do not exaggerate your symptoms to compensate for their bias. This doctor wants you to lie so the insurance company can call all of your injuries into question. The doctor may even invite you to exaggerate by suggesting that certain body parts may hurt, hoping you’ll lie and agree. If your neck only hurts when you move it side to side, don’t say it hurts when you bend it up and down. Certain injuries will lend themselves to certain painful movements while not causing pain to others. For example, a shoulder injury may cause it to be painful to lift something with your arm extended in front of you but not cause pain when you lift something with your arm at your side. Describe the pain as it is, not as you think it should be or as the doctor suggests it should be. That said, if the doctor does something that causes you pain, let him or her know, even if you are not asked. Otherwise, the IME doc will assume that your silence means “no pain.”

Do Not Socialize

If this doctor is clever, he or she will probably be nice and try to get you into a talkative mood. Be polite, but don’t treat this meeting as a social conversation. The insurance company and their attorneys pay the IME doctor. The IME doctor doesn’t need to know your kids play in Little League or how you feel about your job. Remember why you are there, and assume that anything you volunteer outside of medical information will come back to haunt you. This is not your treating doctor. Everything you tell the doctor will be relayed to the defense attorney. Occasionally, I have seen IME doctors try to have plaintiffs fill out “exit interview” or “feedback” questionnaires asking about their feelings about the medical exam. Do not fill this out. Politely decline and leave. The last thing you want is your positive review of this doctor’s exam being used against you in court. If you give a negative review, the doctor may characterize you as hostile and imply that you were not forthcoming during the exam because you didn’t like him or her. These exit interview forms are a no-win proposition — so it is best not to fill them out.

The IME Report

After every IME, the doctor will generate a written report of his or her findings, which your attorney will receive within a month or so after the exam. Ask your attorney to let you see the report when he or she gets it, and note any inaccuracies. Make sure the IME doctor did not put any words in your mouth. Note any complaints you made to the doctor which are not reflected in the report. Expect that the doctor will minimize your injuries as much as possible. The doctor may even claim that your injuries are unrelated to your accident. This is typical, and there is nothing you can do about it. You are mainly concerned with the facts, not the IME doctor’s opinions. Your lawyer will address the doctor’s opinions when the time comes.